I Think People Need To Understand That When Someone Says The Situation In Israel/Palestine Is Complicated

I think people need to understand that when someone says the situation in Israel/Palestine is complicated they are not necessarily saying that the discussion of who the oppressor vs oppressed is complicated. The Israeli government has been oppressing the Palestinians for a very long time, that is clear, and it is not complicated to understand that at least since the 80s they have had dramatically more financial and military power to keep control of the territory in the way they like.

However, it is reductive and dismissive to insist that there is no complexity in the potential ways to move forward to bring peace to the region. Despite what people on tumblr.edu like to believe, "Israel should never have been created" is not a practical solution to an incredibly heated geopolitical situation in the present day. Israel was created and it does exist. 10 million people live there. 74% of the population is native born and the country has existed for 75 years. Hand waving these fact away with the opinion that "they should move back to where they came from" may make you feel good about being a Radical Leftist, but it does not give anyone a road map for how exactly millions of people without dual citizenship are supposed to just up and evaporate. Nor does it acknowledge the reality that 21% of Israelis are Arabs, the very people you are claiming to want to give the land back to.

Insisting that there's nothing complicated about expecting an entire country's population to willingly dissappear with no consequences is not a productive way to think about this conflict. It ignores the many massive superpowers that have an interest in proping up different states in the region, the power dynamics involved in any land back movements, and the inevitably negative consequences of totally dissolving an established state without a plan. It is also completely and almost comically unrealistic, so much so that it makes it hard to believe that anyone who's opinion starts and ends with this idea really gives a shit about anyone who lives in the area as much as they care about their online leftist clout.

There's nothing complicated in understanding that the Israeli government is and has been maintaining an oppressive apartheid state for decades. It is, however, very complicated to come up with a realistic way to resolve some of the most intricately entangled land disputes on the planet without plunging the region into total chaos. Not everyone has to be deeply educated on every geopolitical situation, but it is very hard to take people seriously when they know nothing about the politics or history of a region and yet insist that there is nothing complicated about it at all.

There's a lot of people on this website who are getting dangerously smug about their own ignorance, and are starting to go down Qanon type anti-intellectual paths in the name of being sufficiently radical. Not knowing the details of a very convoluted land dispute isn't something to brag about online as you call for intentionally reductive solutions. You can support the Palestinian cause and be aware of the oppression they have faced while also holding off on calling people trying to do real analysis and de-escalation work bootlickers. We need to get control of the urge to fit every global issue into a simplistic YA novel narrative structure that appeals to Western revolutionary fantasies.

More Posts from Orangesandlemons3 and Others

7 years ago
This Is My Life. It Would Have Been So Cool For Sasori To Be Gaara’s Weird Uncle And The Head Of Puppet

This is my life. It would have been so cool for Sasori to be Gaara’s weird uncle and the head of Puppet Corps and be a mentor to Kankuro. So much wasted potential…


Tags
9 months ago
The Caged Bird And The Cage Keeper
The Caged Bird And The Cage Keeper
The Caged Bird And The Cage Keeper
The Caged Bird And The Cage Keeper
The Caged Bird And The Cage Keeper

The Caged Bird and the Cage Keeper

1 year ago
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved
Zoozve, My Beloved

Zoozve, my beloved

1 year ago

I was reading this shitty horror novella, and one detail that really stuck out to me is that this girl main character (who wore a nightgown throughout) was surprised by her period, and out of shame took off her soiled underwear and hid them. this wasn’t her first period or anything, it just caught her off guard. which, sure, that happens. but she then proceeded to walk around the house underwearless for the rest of the novella. I was reading this like………so is she just freebleeding??? is she leaving a trail everywhere she goes? what’s happening here? is the nightgown white? is she bleeding up the place in her white nightgown while everyone else is too polite to comment on it? she has multiple conversations with other people. are they blind? do they not care? is this normal?

after I finished the book I looked up the author, and it was a cis dude. that was a big ohhhh moment. like he just didn’t know…..that he wrote a novella about a freebleeder. he didn’t know that he was creating this insanity-inducing situation with no explanation. but did his editor not know? did nobody who initially read it know? why didn’t they know? what’s happening?

1 year ago

I know "60s housewives who invented slash fanfiction" has taken on a life of its own as a phrase, but Kirk/Spock didn't really exist until the 70s and THOSE WOMEN HAD JOBS. They were teachers and librarians and bookkeepers and scientists and they damn well spent their own money going to conventions, printing zines, buying fanart and making fandom happen. Put some respect on their names.

7 years ago
Crazy Concept: The Sound Five Having Fun And Hanging Out, Buying Dorky Shirts And Pissing Off Sakon And
Crazy Concept: The Sound Five Having Fun And Hanging Out, Buying Dorky Shirts And Pissing Off Sakon And
Crazy Concept: The Sound Five Having Fun And Hanging Out, Buying Dorky Shirts And Pissing Off Sakon And

Crazy concept: The Sound Five having fun and hanging out, buying dorky shirts and pissing off Sakon and Ukon


Tags
10 months ago

people who don't know anything about academics: man y'all are stuffy and boring what's up with that? actual academics: *too busy fist-fighting each other over the beryllium problem or the existence of a dentistry profession in ancient egypt to reply*

1 year ago

I want to write a movie that is sort of the flip side of a Hallmark holiday movie. Not an anti-Hallmark movie, just like the other side of the same coin.

It starts with a well-dressed professional woman driving a convertible along a country road, autumn foliage in the background, terribly scenic. She turns onto a dirt road/long driveway, and stops next to a field of Christmas trees, all growing in neat, ordered rows, perfectly trimmed and pruned to form. She steps out of the car--no, she's not wearing high-heels, give her some sense!--and knocks on the door of a worn but nice-looking farmhouse. An older woman, late fifties maybe, answers the door, looking a bit puzzled. The younger woman asks if she can buy a Christmas tree now, today. The older woman says they don't do retail sales--and the younger woman breaks down crying.

Cut to the two women sitting at the kitchen table with cups of tea. The young woman (Michelle), no longer actively crying, explains that her mother loves Christmas more than anything, but is in the hospital with end-stage cancer. Her doctors don't think she'll live to see December, let alone Christmas. Nobody is selling Christmas trees in September, so could the older woman please make an exception, just this once? The older woman (Helen) regretfully explains that they have a contract to sell their trees that forbids outside sales. The younger woman nods, starts to stand up, but the older woman stops her with a hand and asks her what hospital her mother is in. After she answers the older woman says that "my Joe" will deliver a tree the next day. "Contract says I can't sell you a tree, but nothing says I can't give you one."

Next day "Joe" shows up at the hospital in flannel and jeans, with a smallish tree over her shoulder. Oh, whoops, that's Jo, Helen's daughter, short for Joanna, not Joe. Jo sets up the tree and even pulls out a box of lights and ornaments. Mother watches from hospital bed with a big smile as Jo and Michelle decorate the tree. Cue "end of movie" type sappiness as nurses and other patients gather in the doorway, smiling at the tree.

Cut to Michelle sitting in her dark apartment, clutching a mug of tea, staring out at the falling snow and the Christmas lights outside. Her apartment has no tree, no decorations, nothing. She starts at a knock on the door, goes to open it. Jo is standing there, again holding a tree over her shoulder.

Plot develops: the second tree is a gift, because Michelle might as well get it as the bank. The contract for the tree sales was an /option/ contract, which prevents them from selling to anyone else, but doesn't guarantee the sale. The corporation with the option isn't going to buy the trees, but Helen and Jo can't sell them anywhere else, and basically they get nothing. They'll lose the farm without the year's income. Michelle asks to see the contract and Jo promises to email it to her.

Next day at a very upscale law firm, Michelle asks at the end of a staff meeting if anyone in contract law still needs pro bono hours for the year. No one does, but a senior partner (Abe) takes her to his office and asks about it. She says the contract looks hinky to her ("Is that a legal term?" "Yes.") but contract law's not her thing. He raises an eyebrow and she grins and pulls a sheaf of paper out of her bag and hands it over. He reads it over, then looks up at her. "They signed this?"

More plot develops. Abe calls in underlings--interns, paralegals, whatever--and the contract is examined, dissected, and ultimately shredded (metaphorically). It's worse even than it looks--on January 1st Helen and Jo will have to repay the advanced they received at signing. The corporation has bought up a suspicious number of Christmas tree farms in previous years after foreclosure, etc.

Cut to Abe explaining all this to Helen and Jo while sitting with them and Michelle in a very swanky conference room. The firm is willing to take on the case pro bono, hopefully as a class's action suit for other farmers trapped by the contract--but there's no way it can go to court before January. Which will be too late to save the farm's income for the year. They might get enough in damages to tide them over, but….

After Michelle sees Helen and Jo out, she comes back and asks Abe if there's anything they can do immediately. Abe looks thoughtful for a long moment, then gets a really shark-like grin on his face. "Maybe…."

Cut to Helen wearing a bathrobe, coming into her kitchen in the morning. She looks out the window…and there's a food truck stopped in her driveway. She pulls a coat on over her robe and goes out--two more trucks have pulled up while she does this. Driver of the first truck asks her where they park. Another truck pulls up behind the others. Behind that is a black BMW--Abe rolls down the window and waves. Helen directs the trucks to the empty field/yard next to the house. Abe pulls up next to Helen's car and Jo's truck and parks. He and Michelle get out--Abe wearing a total power suit, Michelle in weekend casual.

The case will be easier if the corporation initially sues them for violating the (uninforcible!) contract, rather than them suing to corporation (damn if I know, but it's movie logic). So they're going to sell the trees now, and rounded up some food trucks and whatnot to draw people in.

Cue montage of Jo and Michelle running around helping people set up while Abe and Helen watch from the kitchen table. The table starts out covered in file folders…and slowly gains coffee cups and plates of cinnamon rolls. It becomes increasingly clear here that Abe and Helen are becoming as close as Jo and Michelle.

Everything gets set up and a very urban, very motley crowd appears--tats and studs and multiracial couples and LGBTQ parents and everything--and everyone is having a wonderful time eating funnel cake and choosing their tree so Jo and a bunch of rainbow-haired elves can cut it for them. At which point someone shows up from the corporation (maybe with a sheriff's deputy?) and starts yelling at Helen, who's running checkout. And suddenly Abe appears from the house and you realize why he's wearing that suit on a Saturday….

Cue confrontation and corporate flunky running off with their tail between their legs, blustering about suing. Cue Jo kissing Michelle. Cue Helen walking over and putting a hand on Abe's shoulder and smiling at her.

I want the lawyers to be the heroes because they are lawyers and know the law. I want a lesbian who lives in the country with her mother. I want urbanites to turn out as a community to help someone who isn't even part of their community. I want Michelle to keep working at her high-power job, loving Christmas and grieving her mother.

  • rawdogimus-prime
    rawdogimus-prime liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • mandelatechnician
    mandelatechnician reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • marieshitposts
    marieshitposts liked this · 1 month ago
  • lady12maiden
    lady12maiden reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • definitely-not-the-rat-king
    definitely-not-the-rat-king liked this · 2 months ago
  • jawz
    jawz liked this · 2 months ago
  • atlasorters
    atlasorters liked this · 2 months ago
  • pulvis--sidereus
    pulvis--sidereus liked this · 2 months ago
  • serial-lurker-lain
    serial-lurker-lain liked this · 2 months ago
  • lexkent
    lexkent liked this · 2 months ago
  • sapphocookie
    sapphocookie liked this · 2 months ago
  • transfemleo
    transfemleo liked this · 2 months ago
  • elfpylon
    elfpylon liked this · 2 months ago
  • vigilante-duck-hawk
    vigilante-duck-hawk liked this · 2 months ago
  • tirfpikachu
    tirfpikachu reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • mint-fem
    mint-fem reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • lady12maiden
    lady12maiden liked this · 3 months ago
  • dionysiandevotee
    dionysiandevotee liked this · 3 months ago
  • bluejay-7
    bluejay-7 liked this · 4 months ago
  • runefaustblack
    runefaustblack liked this · 4 months ago
  • awwooooooo
    awwooooooo liked this · 4 months ago
  • burnyourdiaries
    burnyourdiaries liked this · 5 months ago
  • annai8avx
    annai8avx liked this · 5 months ago
  • annacwaht
    annacwaht liked this · 5 months ago
  • eclipes-j-blog
    eclipes-j-blog liked this · 6 months ago
  • marigoldinbloom
    marigoldinbloom liked this · 6 months ago
  • porsche1955
    porsche1955 liked this · 7 months ago
  • sanssavoirpourquoi
    sanssavoirpourquoi liked this · 7 months ago
  • luckyteenagedirtbag
    luckyteenagedirtbag liked this · 7 months ago
  • cozmicclockwork
    cozmicclockwork liked this · 7 months ago
  • ehelbling
    ehelbling reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • sagescented
    sagescented liked this · 8 months ago
  • diogenescamus
    diogenescamus reblogged this · 8 months ago
  • diogenescamus
    diogenescamus liked this · 8 months ago
  • walker-of-the-yellow-path
    walker-of-the-yellow-path liked this · 8 months ago
  • godofmurder
    godofmurder liked this · 9 months ago
  • rainhanautilus
    rainhanautilus liked this · 9 months ago
  • screamnpatches
    screamnpatches reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • screamnpatches
    screamnpatches liked this · 9 months ago
  • gingerswagfreckles
    gingerswagfreckles reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • gingerswagfreckles
    gingerswagfreckles reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • kwrightsfinesthour
    kwrightsfinesthour liked this · 9 months ago
  • blindcathar
    blindcathar liked this · 9 months ago
  • urbanpineapplefarmer
    urbanpineapplefarmer liked this · 9 months ago
  • aceforestnymph
    aceforestnymph reblogged this · 9 months ago
  • aceforestnymph
    aceforestnymph liked this · 9 months ago
orangesandlemons3 - Orange the Ace
Orange the Ace

Hi! Nice to meet you.

374 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags